MoMoBookDiary

My review

Daniel Sellers delivers a gripping locked-room-style mystery set in a storm-battered Scottish castle. Murder at Ardaig Castle is the fifth book in the Detective Lola Harris Mysteries series, but it works well as a standalone for those new to the series—like me.

The novel follows Detective Lola Harris as she takes a much-needed break at an exclusive wellness retreat in the Scottish Highlands. But relaxation quickly turns to tension when she learns of the sinister poison pen letters that have been sent to staff over recent weeks. When a body is discovered within the castle, Lola is forced into action, navigating a web of secrets, grudges, and hidden pasts. With the storm cutting off access to the castle, the pressure mounts as she races to unmask the murderer before they strike again.

From the outset, the novel hooked me. A cut-off castle, a murderer on the loose, and a varied cast of characters—perfect ingredients for a classic whodunnit. Sellers does a fantastic job of crafting an atmospheric setting, using the castle’s hidden passageways, dark hallways, and eerie basement to heighten the tension. His descriptive writing pulls the reader straight into the howling wind and relentless rain outside, making the setting feel as much a character as the people within its walls.

Speaking of characters, the guests at the exclusive retreat are suitably wealthy, entitled, and largely unlikable, which only adds to the intrigue. There’s no shortage of suspects, and I was surprised by the final reveal. The mystery is well-paced, with plenty of twists and red herrings to keep you guessing.

While I thoroughly enjoyed the novel, there were moments when the pacing felt drawn out. Perhaps my unfamiliarity with the series played a role, as I lacked prior connection with Lola Harris. However, this book stands on its own merit, and I appreciated the depth Sellers brought to his protagonist.

I was initially drawn to this book without seeing the cover, but once I did, I was thrilled—it perfectly captures the dark and brooding landscape I love in a mystery thriller. If you enjoy a well-crafted whodunnit with an eerie, atmospheric setting and a locked-room mystery twist, Murder at Ardaig Castle is an ideal read for a cold, stormy night.

This is a well-written, immersive mystery that keeps you engaged from start to finish. Though a bit drawn out in places, the novel delivers a compelling plot, strong atmosphere, and an enjoyable puzzle to unravel. I’d definitely consider reading more from the series to get better acquainted with Detective Lola Harris.